The Fifth Fourth

A secret prediction is placed writing-side down onto the table. Four cards, each with an individually- colored name (person, movie, song, etc.) written on its face, are shown to have been previously torn into four pieces each. These sixteen pieces are mixed together by the spectator and then re-dealt into four face-down, four- piece piles. The top piece of each pile is turned over...and they do not appear to match at all. Oopsies. The prediction is then turned over to reveal a completely different name altogether. Double oopsies. When all hope seems lost, the four pieces are reassembled and shown to actually match the prediction perfectly. And as a special "fifth fourth" bonus, upon further examination, these four individual pieces actually physically fit together perfectly...as if they came from the same freakin' card.